Fidelity (Employee Dishonesty) Insurance
Protect your business from the financial devastation of employee fraud, embezzlement, and theft.
Get a Quote →What is Fidelity Insurance?
Fidelity insurance — also called employee dishonesty insurance — covers financial losses your business suffers as a direct result of fraudulent or dishonest acts by your employees. This includes embezzlement, theft of cash or assets, forgery of payment instructions, and other deliberate criminal acts by staff. Employee fraud is estimated to cost businesses hundreds of millions of dollars annually.
Research consistently shows that the majority of business fraud is committed by trusted, often long-tenured employees — not strangers. The average employee fraud runs for 18 months before detection and causes $150,000+ in losses. Fidelity insurance is available as a standalone policy or as part of a broader commercial crime package, with coverage available from specialist brokers including Rothbury and Unite Insurance.
Key Risks This Covers
- Cash theft from registers or petty cash
- Embezzlement of funds over time
- Fraudulent invoicing or vendor payments to self
- Payroll fraud (ghost employees, false overtime)
- Theft of stock, equipment, or client assets
What Fidelity Insurance Covers
- Direct financial loss from employee theft or embezzlement
- Fraudulent transfer of business funds
- Forged authorisation of payments
- Theft of physical property or stock
- Payroll fraud and ghost employees
- Discovery-based cover (losses uncovered after the event)
Who Needs Fidelity Insurance?
Typical Premium Range
Fidelity insurance premiums typically start from around $800-$2,000 per year for basic cover, depending on the number of employees, turnover, and financial controls in place.
What is Fidelity Insurance?
Fidelity insurance — also called fidelity guarantee insurance or employee dishonesty insurance — is a specialist business insurance product that covers direct financial losses caused by the dishonest or fraudulent acts of employees. It is one of the oldest forms of commercial insurance, and one of the most consistently misunderstood. The core protection is straightforward: if an employee steals money, embezzles funds, or commits fraud that causes a direct financial loss to the business, fidelity insurance reimburses that loss (subject to policy terms and limits). The term "fidelity" references the loyalty — or faithfulness — expected of employees. When that loyalty is betrayed, the insurance steps in. The policy may be called "fidelity insurance," "employee dishonesty insurance," or "fidelity guarantee" depending on the insurer and jurisdiction. In New Zealand, you will encounter all three terms. Fidelity insurance differs from commercial crime insurance in scope. Fidelity is specifically and exclusively about internal employee dishonesty — acts committed by your own staff, against your own business. Commercial crime insurance is broader: it covers fidelity as a subset but also extends to external criminal acts such as computer fraud by third parties, forgery of documents by outsiders, and counterfeit currency. For many businesses, a commercial crime policy that encompasses fidelity within a broader package is the preferred approach.
Why Employee Fraud Is Your Biggest Financial Risk
The most counterintuitive finding in business fraud research is also the most important: the greatest fraud threat to most businesses is not hackers, not scammers, not external fraudsters — it is trusted employees. Global research from the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) — the most comprehensive study of occupational fraud — consistently finds: - 43% of fraudsters have been employed by their victim organisation for more than five years - The median single fraud loss exceeds $150,000 - The average fraud scheme runs for 18 months before detection - Over 90% of fraudsters had no prior criminal record These patterns mirror what is observed locally. The profile of the typical employee fraudster is not a reckless opportunist — it is a trusted, long-serving employee in a position of financial access and responsibility. They are often well-regarded by colleagues and management. The extended tenure is precisely what enables long-running frauds: the employee understands the control environment, knows where the gaps are, and has accumulated enough trust that oversight is minimal. The 18-month average detection lag is particularly significant. A business losing $10,000 per month to employee embezzlement that goes undetected for 18 months faces a $180,000 loss — well above the cost of three to four years of fidelity insurance premiums. Personal financial stress is a common trigger: ACFE data shows approximately half of fraudsters are experiencing financial difficulties (debt, divorce, gambling, medical costs) at the time of the fraud. This does not excuse the behaviour, but it helps explain why background checks alone are not sufficient — they capture prior convictions, not current pressures.
What Fidelity Insurance Covers in New Zealand
A fidelity insurance policy covers direct financial losses caused by dishonest or fraudulent acts committed by employees of the business. Key coverage categories include: Cash Theft: Physical theft of cash from registers, petty cash funds, safes, or cash in transit. Common in retail, hospitality, gaming, and any business with significant cash handling. Embezzlement of Business Funds: The most common and highest-value fraud type — gradually diverting business funds to personal accounts through false invoices, duplicate payments, or direct bank transfers. Can run for years before detection. Ghost Employees and Payroll Fraud: Creating fictitious employees on the payroll and redirecting their salaries, or inflating hours worked for existing employees with the approval of a colluding supervisor. Particularly common in larger organisations with complex payroll systems. Fraudulent Payment Authorisations: Forging the signature or authorisation of a business owner, director, or authorised signatory on payment instructions, cheques, or electronic fund transfer approvals. Stock and Asset Theft: Systematic removal of inventory, equipment, or physical business assets. Common in retail, warehousing, and manufacturing. Unauthorised Fund Transfers: Directing payments to personal accounts or controlled third parties using legitimate access to banking systems. This form of fraud exploits the employee's authorised system access to initiate fraudulent transactions. Most fidelity policies are written on a "blanket" basis — covering all employees without needing to specify individuals. This is important because the fraudster is typically not who you would expect.
The Claims Process Explained
When you discover — or suspect — employee fraud, the steps you take in the immediate aftermath significantly affect your ability to recover both the funds and the insurance claim. What Triggers a Claim: Fidelity insurance responds when you discover that an employee has committed a dishonest act that caused a direct financial loss. You don't need certainty — reasonable grounds for suspecting fraud is typically sufficient to trigger the notification obligation. Do not wait until you have proven the fraud beyond doubt before notifying your insurer and broker. Documentation Required: When making a claim, you will typically need to provide: a detailed account of how the fraud was discovered; quantification of the loss with supporting documentation (bank statements, invoices, payroll records, accounts reconciliation); identification of the employee(s) involved (if known); and evidence that the loss resulted from a dishonest act (not an error). Police Report Requirement: Most fidelity insurers require or strongly encourage you to report the fraud to NZ Police. This creates an official record and may assist with evidence gathering. File a report with NZ Police (105) and note the case number. This is separate from the insurance claim, which can proceed independently. No Conviction Needed: Critically, a criminal conviction is not required to make a successful fidelity insurance claim. You need to establish on the balance of probabilities that the employee committed the dishonest act. Many fraud cases settle with the employee leaving without criminal prosecution — a fidelity claim can still succeed in these circumstances. Typical Resolution Timeline: Straightforward fidelity claims with clear evidence can resolve in 3-6 months. Complex cases involving forensic accounting, disputed facts, or large dollar amounts can take 12+ months. Engaging a specialist forensic accountant from the outset can expedite the process.
Fidelity Insurance Providers in New Zealand
Fidelity insurance in New Zealand is primarily accessed through specialist insurance brokers. Unlike some insurance types where direct online purchase is common, fidelity and commercial crime insurance is almost always brokered, given the complexity and the need for tailored advice. Rothbury Insurance Brokers: One of the largest NZ-owned brokers, Rothbury has specialist expertise in commercial crime and fidelity products. They can access multiple underwriters and provide comparative advice for businesses of all sizes. Unite Insurance: A specialist NZ broker with focus on the SME segment. Unite Insurance offers fidelity products suitable for small businesses that may find larger broker minimums prohibitive. Marsh NZ: The local arm of the global Marsh brokerage, Marsh specialises in larger corporate and mid-market risks. For businesses with complex exposures or high-limit requirements, Marsh can access Lloyd's of London and international markets in addition to local insurers. Cover4You Referral: FraudInsurance.co.nz connects businesses with licensed insurance advisers who can assist with fidelity and commercial crime insurance. Submit a quote request through our form and a licensed adviser will be in contact. When selecting a provider, the most important considerations are: the breadth of coverage (does it include discovery-period extensions?), the limit available relative to your maximum exposure, and whether social engineering and computer fraud are included or available as extensions.
Prevention + Insurance: A Combined Strategy
Insurance and prevention work best together — and in the case of fidelity insurance, good controls actually reduce your premium while also reducing the likelihood and scale of losses. Key preventive controls: Dual Authorisation for Payments: Require two separate authorisations for payments above a threshold. Make this a genuine control — two people checking independently, not one person countersigning without review. This single control stops a significant proportion of embezzlement attempts. Segregation of Duties: No single person should control a financial process from initiation to completion. The person who writes the cheque should not be the person who reconciles the bank statement. The person who approves invoices should not be the person who processes payments. In small businesses, this may mean the business owner personally reviewing reconciliations. Reference and Background Checks: Conduct proper reference checks for all employees with financial access. Credit and criminal background checks are appropriate for senior finance roles. Regular Surprise Reconciliations: Periodic unannounced audits of accounts payable, payroll, and petty cash. Scheduled annual audits are important, but fraudsters know when they're coming. Surprise audits are significantly more effective at detecting ongoing fraud. Encourage Reporting: Anonymous reporting channels (tip lines, email reporting) enable colleagues who suspect fraud to raise concerns without personal risk. ACFE data shows that tips are the most common method by which fraud is initially detected — more effective than audits or management reviews. Why controls don't eliminate the need for insurance: Even the strongest control environments fail. Controls require human application, and humans make mistakes, are colluded with, or are overridden by people in authority. Fidelity insurance is the financial backstop that covers the cases where controls are circumvented. The premium is modest; the protection is material.
Fidelity Insurance Costs and Coverage Limits
Fidelity insurance is among the most cost-effective business insurances available relative to the risk it covers. For most SMEs, coverage is accessible and affordable. Typical Premium Ranges: - Small businesses (under 10 staff, under $1m turnover): from $800-$1,500 per year for $100,000-$500,000 in cover - Medium businesses (10-50 staff, $1-10m turnover): $1,500-$4,000 per year for $500,000-$2m in cover - Larger businesses and professional services firms: $3,000-$10,000+ for $2-5m limits These are indicative ranges — your specific premium will depend on the factors discussed below. Coverage Limits: Policy limits for fidelity insurance typically range from $100,000 (minimum for most policies) to $5 million or more for large corporates. Setting the right limit is critical: the limit should represent the maximum plausible loss your business could suffer from a single fraud scheme, taking into account the employee with the greatest financial access and the length of time a fraud could go undetected in your control environment. Excess Levels: Most fidelity policies have a minimum excess (deductible) — often $1,000-$5,000. Higher excesses reduce premium but mean you absorb more of smaller losses. Coverage Period Nuances: Discovery-based policies cover losses discovered during the policy period, regardless of when the fraud occurred. This is generally the preferred form. Loss-sustained policies cover losses that occurred during the policy period — a subtle but important distinction that can leave gaps if a fraud spans policy periods. Always clarify the basis of coverage with your broker. The value proposition is compelling: a $1,500 annual premium providing $1 million of fidelity cover against a $150,000 average fraud loss represents an extraordinary risk transfer for most businesses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Most fidelity policies cover all employees as a blanket — you don't need to specify individual names. However, some policies have provisions allowing you to exclude certain individuals or require that you conduct reference and credit checks for financial roles. Check with your broker about your policy's exact coverage.
Related Insurance Types
Get a Tailored Quote
Complete our brief form and a licensed adviser will contact you with options for Fidelity Insurance.
Start Free Quote →Key Providers
By Business Sector
This page provides general information only. Insurance needs vary by business. Always consult a licensed insurance adviser before purchasing. Our quote form connects you to licensed advisers only.
Protect Your Business from Fidelity (Employee Dishonesty) Insurance
Get a tailored quote from a licensed insurance adviser — no obligation, no pressure.
Get a Free Business Quote →